I didnt think the bulk of Americans, there was this really great moment at the very beginning of the focused group about national divorce with the Trump voters, where her comments were brought up, and most of the Zoom room laughed. Quebec and Canada has had various referendum about secession and leaving. Yeah. The bad news is the term for that group of people is the exhausted majority. Weegy: The revolutionary war affected Loyalists by About one hundred thousand became refugees.User: What impact did many state constitutions have on the separation of church and state affairs? Can you imagine a United States of Latin America? Compare And Contrast French Revolution And American | ipl.org Throughout history there have been many wars and revolutions. Right. The causes of the revolutions in France and America were very similar. American Reaction to the French Revolution - ThoughtCo was such a textbook example of countless conversations Ive had since late twenty fifteen, which is one of the responses people have to some of the most outrageous rhetoric on the right whether it comes from Trump or it comes from Marjorie Taylor Green or Matt Gates, or you name it, is they laugh. The thesis of the book is really stated in the first sentence of the book, which is that there isnt any truly national, cultural, religious, social, political trend that is pulling us together more than its pushing us apart. Finally, they were connected by economic and political networks. You were just talking about it, about this latest thing with Fox News and what makes me so mad about that Fox News thing is and you hit this. If youre working in a McDonalds for a manager, if youre working in an in assurance company for the manager, you name it. And And I said, well, how was your voting experience? There was a mixture of communities throughout the American colonies, there was loyalist communities, and there were revolutionary communities, and they were often in the same city, they were often in the same colony, in secession, there were parts of the south that didnt want to secede. Right. A lot of the critique of the Trump era are going to be mystifying to you. How effective they can be? The French Revolution was a conflict rooted in envy with desperate peasants whipped into a frenzy. Furthermore, according to recent surveys by Israeli media outlets KAN and N12, only 24-28% of the general electorate are in favor of this revolution. We dont know anything about compromise. Two revolutions, both taking place in the 18th Century, both world-changing. Well, we just heard some of the the ways in which this happens. Thats when were in a very dangerous place. So I dont know. The American Revolution, sparked by conflict over British rule and influenced by Enlightenment ideas, broke colonial ties with a monarchy and yielded a new nation. During this time period, there were several revolutions that occurred throughout the developing world. The American and the French Revolutions - PapersOwl.com All revolutions have many stages which they go through, these three stages are the main bits of a, The American Revolution and the French Revolution have similar and different causes to their revolution. Use evidence from this article and other material in this lesson to defend your claim. When the king called the Estates General, the Third Estate suddenly had a voice. Both these revolutions had the similar cause, effects, and stages that resulted . You and I are frequently on the same page about this. I like transparency and I like accountability. The sphere of liberty in the US is broad enough to wear a variety of communities can live side by side with each other. Although the Civil War and American Revolution shared many similarities, the Civil War differed in the fact that it was more of a confrontation of two opposing. What made the American Revolution look most like a civil war, though, was the reality that about one-third of the colonists, known as loyalists (or Tories), continued to support and fought on the side of the crown. What were the major causes of the American Revolution? Or if youre a typical Democrat, you believe that the average Republican is a lot more extreme than they are. Ironically, the transcription service has particular problems with the word bulwark, so you may see it mangled as Bullard, Boulart, or even bull word. Enjoy! We have seen media scandals. Yeah. The French populace was divided into three estates. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. The late 18th and 19th century brought about the French and Haitian Revolutions. They see a, like, a mirror image on the other side. Until early in 1778 the conflict was a civil war within the British Empire, but afterward it became an international war as France (in 1778) and Spain (in 1779) joined the colonies against Britain. Though the Third Estate represented many more people and had twice the number of delegates, each estate had an equal vote. But in any event, so there are things that they said that I wasnt wild about. Thats right. The debt from this huge war helped spark the American and French Revolutions. Are the ideals as described in federalist ten good? I do think that movements can be learning organisms. Yeah. Until early in 1778, the American Revolution was a civil war within the British Empire, but it became an international war as France (in 1778) and Spain (in 1779) joined the colonies against Britain. Oh, you cant take that seriously. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth. So I like to draw a distinction between earned distrust and manufactured distrust. Using the language of the Enlightenment, they initially tried to promote harmony between France's social classes and establish a constitutional monarchy with King Louis still on a throne. No, its more secure. The Mexican Revolution for Independence lasted for 11 years from 1810-1821. media. And then heres the other problem, Sarah Longwell can point to scandals, you know, in mainstream or left wing media, and that are real that happened and are bad. Theres a, oh, thats ridiculous. mean, when did Chris Ruffo become a traitor to the cause? His idea was the separation of powers so its balanced, as in what we still use. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices. Because these are the people who sort of know better, but theres no leader or anybody else who is appealing to the good nature thats inside of them that you hear coming out and is pulling on those best instincts to say we have to resist this. The all-day siege and capture of the royal fortress by a mob of revolutionaries resulted in more than 100 dead or wounded rioters, as well as the murder of the fortress' military governor, Bernard-Jordan de Launay. And you just kinda go back to talking about SEC football, but. This is where Right. We are having this really great conversation. And so, you know, I think just to set the stage for this conversation, can you just give us like the thesis of the book? For a national divorce or a civil war. In other words, thats dangerous. Its what the media does to it. Or is that just negative partisanship all the way down? And everybody wants to stay here. Suddenly, the Latin American colonies found themselves without a direct European power telling them what to do. And Ive always liked this formulation that there was absolutely a recessive gene within the Republican party. This is not really being covered Right. You could do worse. And they they do lean right, absolutely. New York Times opinion columnist David French (literally) wrote the book on a possible national divorce. PDF. For the first time I started to see some reappraisals. Right? Denis Diderot also a French enlightenment thinker created an encyclopedia that explained the new ideas on the topics of government, philosophy, and religion. And I think the fox revelation should be very sobering because what they have told us is that, you know, weve talked about the power of leadership leadership has exerted such power for so long, that Im starting to wonder how much attempts to counter the flow of this river. Yeah. Yeah. So you went from holding your nose in twenty sixteen to third bass boat in the boat parade in twenty twenty. But Marjorie Taylor Greens social circle notwithstanding, theres no doubt our country is facing deep internal divisions. Its been a long time. This is never gonna happen. Theyre not always accurate either. Revolutions can be contagious. And the answer is the one you feed. Lets listen. The government and leadership in France was corrupt as they were in much debt. The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. It tells you an awful lot. As a reminder, this should be a quick process! They come to us, like, belatedly, and its because, like, Liz Shady. Even then theyd find ballots back to somebodys trunk, but it was a lot more difficult. But then once this minority group because remember Trump clench the nomination with the lowest percentage of the popular vote in the history of the Republican open primary era. And I dont know enough about them to know if theyre trustworthy or not either. INSTEAD OF A BLUE STATE. The Proposed "Judicial Revolution" in Israel: What Can we Learn from An MTG isnt the only high profile figure to raise the prospect of secession, national divorce and civil war over the past few years. Omissions? Right? The war followed more than a decade of growing estrangement between the British crown and a large and influential segment of its North American colonies that was caused by British attempts to assert greater control over colonial affairs after having long adhered to a policy of salutary neglect. But a unified Latin America remained a dream only. But the idea that between the two people on January sixth, Trump, who wanted to overturn the election in Pence, who had stood by Trump every second of the four years prior, and who drew the line at a coup was going to then lose his standing and become a what happened to Mike Pences situation. The nation of Haiti formally declared its independence on January 1, 1804. And now you can talk, but Im so bad about this. And one of the most disturbing pieces of data that Ive seen is watching the contrast between Mike Pence and Mitch McConnells approval rating and Donald Trumps after January sixth. Theyre not taking all of what. Oh, man. Right. And youre like, oh my god. And Pence and McConnell who opposed Trumps attempt to overturn the election, their approval rating dropped to such an extent that Mike Pence now who may well run for president is widely viewed as having no standing, no meaningful standing. In five short decades from 1775 to 1825, several revolutions in the Americas and Europe brought down the colonial system and European monarchies that had been profiting from it. And they just kind of back into the shrubbery, and it leaves the field of political engagement to the most angry, most energized minority. they think they should take, and thats a compromise to them. Im fifty seven and Ive never seen it like this. Now, theres no real condemnation to it. The Creole are people of Spanish or Portuguese descent born in the Americas. And theyre just scientists people, but theyre still quite, I would say, of the right in almost all the ways. Now weve seen from twenty twenty two, for example, that there might be a two percent or a three percent or a four percent who are not gonna go that far that will not vote for, say, a Hershel Walker or a whatever. Both areas suffered social and economic hardships that led to the realization that something must be done to topple the hierarchy and put power back into the hands of the people. Dont take that seriously. They just think one might be coming based on what theyre seeing around them. Others were unemployed persons from the urban slums. Were telling everybody dont trust mail in balloting. I wouldnt be surprised if it took another civil war, to be honest. How did the French Revolution impact Saint Domingue? Lets and hes a rhino. Their eyes are wide. Right. But youre right when we read them Marjorie Taylor Greens tweet, here is how they responded. New York Times opinion columnist David French (literally) wrote the book on a possible national divorce. Canada: The influence of the American Revolution, Explore highlights of the Revolutionary War, which won 13 American colonies their political independence from Great Britain, Paul Reveres ride and the Battles of Lexington and Concord, The Siege of Boston and the Battle of Bunker Hill, The surrender at Saratoga and French involvement, Final campaigns in the South and the surrender of Cornwallis, The status of naval forces at the outbreak of war, French intervention and the decisive action at Virginia Capes, Causes and Effects of the American Revolution, https://www.britannica.com/event/American-Revolution, Econlib - Benefits of the American Revolution: An Exploration of Positive Externalities, Boston Tea Party Ships and Museum - American Revolution, American Battlefield Trust - American Revolution Timeline, Humanities LibreTexts - American Revolution, American Revolution - Children's Encyclopedia (Ages 8-11), American Revolution - Student Encyclopedia (Ages 11 and up), skirmishes between British regulars and American provincials on April 19, 1775. This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors and omissions. The french did not have much of a trained army its was more of a rebellion of a certain class of people because not all classes of people supported the french revolution. And and the reason that I like that so much is that what I feel like politicians are doing right now is I believe and no ones gonna talk me out of it that people are essentially good. It's not as if all revolutions challenged every issue. Compare And Contrast The American And French Revolution But before I do that since you brought it up, I wanna hit this set. Both the American Revolution and French Revolution were the products of Enlightenment ideals that emphasized the idea of natural rights and equality. Shes never been conservative about anything. You can be frustrated at how contentious politics are. Oh, which is exactly where we are. The collapse of trust, the collapse of trust in institutions, and the class of trust in each other because you need, like, social fabric is built around a kind of social cohesion and trust. And one of my big concerns is The minority of Americans who are extremely activated politically are extremely polarized and hate each other very much. The American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. With such an ideological basis, it becomes clear when one sets out to compare the French Revolution and American Revolution that people felt the need to be free from oppressive or tyrannical rule of absolute monarchs and have the ability to live independent from such forces. Oh, man. The French was in Europe fighting for freedom against its own government. They need to have a much more clear way to vote like it used to be. So theres somebody else on the other side. Its Why They Play the Game (with Robert Gibbs), DeSanctimonious Deep Dive (with Tara Palmeri). To actively oppose it. Colorful drawings of soldiers In different colored uniforms holding heads on pikes. The total number of the former provided by quotas from the states throughout the conflict was 231,771 men, and the militias totaled 164,087. Although Great Britain, Spain, and France settled in the Americas, their colonies developed in almost completely different ways, like: The Spaniards colonized mainly in South and Central America for economic purposes, like to grow sugar, which lead its colonies to be mainly plantations; The Frenchs main goals in the Americas were to trade fur with the Native Americans and to find a route to the Pacific Ocean to trade with Asia; and the Britishers came here for two main purposes, one for economic matters and to avoid the religious conflict that was happening in England. pulls his name out of the app, a lot of those investigations will automatically disappear. In 1773, the British imposed a new tax, known as the Tea Act. Good standing. States could not support an established church. And so thats sort of this core vision of pluralism. A powerful and popular general named Napoleon Bonaparte soon rose to power and declared himself emperor in 1799. But the revolution soon turned more violent and radical as peasants attacked castles and burned records of their debts. And then, of course, youre gonna be automatically mistrustful of it. Trump broke you. It can happen. In France, the lower classes overthrew the Old Regime. Baron de Montesquieu a French enlightenment thinker developed the ideas of separation of powers and check and balances. The American War of Independence, the French Revolution, the Haitian Revolution, and the many revolutions of Latin America were connected through networks of ideas, trade, and global events that rocked the world over a few dramatic decades. Corrections? And in Latin Americawell that wasn't so clear at the start. Fire the guy who called this race. Is this intentional lying about the election for day, week after week leading up to the attack on the capital on January sixth. energy to do the real logistical Bulwark. Right? The French colony was the richest plantation colony in the world, with around 8,000 plantations that produced 40 percent of the world's sugar and about half of its coffee. Like religious faith and practices not evenly distributed across the United States of America. But we talked about leadership. Because the word exhausted. Were being pushed apart on multiple fronts, including geographically, for example, that people are super clustering into very bright red, into very bright blue parts of the country. Almost had a civil war. But heres the problem, Sarah. Everybody is just button heads. Within the next two years France would completely abolish the nobility and pass its own constitution, establishing a representative democracy. Yeah. We know not to take them seriously. Keyboard warriors are also not the kind of people who are going to stop something once it starts unfolding. And they said, well, we liked it because we voted and then we got a paper print out that showed exactly who we voted for to confirm And then that paper printout was what was actually scanned. been a long time. Whats the solution you get? So number one, Al Yuval Levin has said this very well that theres a George Wallace constituency in American politics. The American and French Revolution are both remembered in history as two major changes that would shape what we know today. Who is always right? And it was that power of the cultural river. And quite literally, Sarah, there is no amount of right wing credentials that can allow you standing to tell folks that Trump has lied terribly or that Tucker Carlson is spouting falsehoods Because the instant you do, then the question isnt what happened to Tucker Mhmm. Thats the key here is that. We make this sphere of liberty bigger. You know what? So what does he say in federalist ten? But then as soon as some Republicans learned that Donald Trump had said some nice things about single payer healthcare, their steam for single repair, health care went up. So how much have we built sort of this cultural stream that is now so powerful that any given individual cant really stand in front of it anymore and say no more no more And however, here is where I will say that Im seeing some signs of hope. Trump was such a bad candidate that he even lost Arizona. The American revolution and the French Revolution are two major incidents happened in the 1700s, which had intense social impacts on both French and American societies. Yeah. After French King Louis XVI was tried and executed on January 21, 1793, war between France and monarchal nations Great Britain and Spain was inevitable. So she has a role to play in the coalition. Cause and outcomes of the North American and French Revolution, Compare View full question and answer details: https://www.wyzant.com/resources/answers/920758/compare-the-cause-and-outcomes-of-the-american-revolution-and-the-fren. Kelly was right. In general, the American Revolution was more successful than the French revolution. Both the Creoles and the church were alarmed by the social radicalism of the revolt and worried that it would end like the French and Haitian revolutions. In the northern regions of Latin America, the revolutionary general Simn Bolvar successfully fought Spanish forces and created a short-lived "Gran Columbia" between 1819 and 1830 that was modeled after the United States. And were having a great conversation and then she turns to me and she says, you know, they sent this tornado to punish the red states. Is voting less secure now than it was back in the day. Theyre sleeping in cots you know, in church fellowship halls to help these folks. And how . A lot of people think this country has headed for a revolution. Meanwhile, the Netherlands, which provided both official recognition of the United States and financial support for it, was engaged in its own war against Britain. The American and French Revolution are both remembered in history as two major changes that would shape what we know today. They voted for him twice though, then this to me, I find myself understanding these people and then also thinking that these are the most dangerous people. They revolted in response to events happening in Europe. right now. Okay. But if were in a position where its even possible, thats a scary thing. If you missed it a couple weeks back, Margery Taylor Green tweeted, we need a national divorce. Like, some some ways, were such couch warriors and, like, keyboard warriors now that Im not sure we could muster. They were swimming along with the course quite merrily. Dont trust mail in and then Fox calls for Arizona, and the whole right wing population or much of it was like, wait, we were told not to trust this process, and theres Fox going ahead and calling this red state for Biden that cant possibly be real. So when we asked about hundred Biden and we said, well, would you trust them if they prosecute you at hundred Biden, hundred percent of his head went up right away. David, my friend, thank you for being here. Thats all the good news. I would believe him. While most Indians wanted to stay out of the American Revolution, they But then theres this whole concept of manufactured distrust. Yeah. So theyre gonna watch Fox and they will know nothing about all of the hosts that one of those people just mentioned as being pretty much straight shooters. (7) $2.00. And so thats why, you know, when I think about National Unity going forward, that exhausted majority So long as the operative word is exhausted and not majority, we face a problem. I mean, of course, nobodys voted yet. And then run the ballots through the machine a few times. Its. The bastille was a jail where all the prisoners were being kept. The French Revolution, inspired by the American Revolution as well as the Enlightenment, freed French citizens from an absolute monarchy and secured equality before the law for all male citizens. For this reading, you should be looking for unfamiliar vocabulary words, the major claim and key supporting details, and analysis and evidence. The American Revolutionalso called the U.S. War of Independencewas the insurrection fought between 1775 and 1783 through which 13 of Great Britain's North American colonies threw off British rule to establish the sovereign United States of America, founded with the Declaration of Independence in 1776. The French navy in particular played a key role in bringing about the British surrender at Yorktown, which effectively ended the war. So they wont know about it. Just like in every warring country, it is inevitable that there will be some change that occurs whether it be for the better or for worse. And that Americans because of the built in infrastructure that we got from our founders are especially inclined toward pluralism. As the ideas spread over the years American and French lives would change slowly. The fundamentals of each revolution, why the citizens were fighting are completely different. The Haitian Revolution (1791-1808) was, more than any other, a social revolution for human rights and equality regardless of skin color. But now Im against it because we have to take care of our own people first. Militias, poorly disciplined and with elected officers, were summoned for periods usually not exceeding three months. You literally wrote the book on the potential of a national divorce. Were like, well, in the beginning, I was for it. Youre gunning straight for liberty, which undermines the American Republic, the American Experiment, and so Madisons you cant do that. This information is like the biggest word out there. We know trust is the problem. And thats one of the burdens of leadership as you have to set that cultural course in the right direction. I think a lot of these recent events are making, it seem like it is a bigger possibility. Both countries have many differences and similarities, ranging from the individuals fighting these wars to tactics and strategies they used to win. My favorite example of that, Sarah, I was volunteering for Samaritans person Mayfield, Kentucky after these terrible tornadoes. They do not like Trump. The numbers dont seem to add up. They continue to trust Fox. And, you know, one of the powers you wanna go back to our founding documents, for example, the statement that all men are created equal and endowed by their creator certain unalienable rights among them, life liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, was setting a cultural course for the United States that we were often contrary to, but had enormous power over the course of the next two centuries plus to where eventually we started to get more and more and more in conformity with that vision. The nobility and clergy blocked King Louis XVI's attempts to raise taxes. Like, is that really what its about? The American Revolution hoped to achieve Independence . He was a brilliant general who defeated Napoleon's attempt to regain French control over the colony. All revolutions have many stages which they go through, these three stages are the main bits of a. About all of this rhetoric. Dont trust mail in balloting. And so theres this absolute unwillingness to sort of say this is so far beyond the pale that Im gonna break with this kind of core sense of identity that I have. And the reappraisal interestingly wasnt just on twenty twenty two. The new government seized and sold church lands. And so And Federalist Ten, what James Madison does is he talks about expanding the sphere of the American Republic. Mhmm. And thats what really concerns me. What classes took power in South America, and how was this different from the class that took power in Saint Domingue? That there was a very troubling part about why Nikki Haley could not be the president, and it was super like well, no world leader would take a woman seriously. Its their input. What factors led to the Atlantic revolution? It sets the course of the cultural river and you see it in military units. They dont give you anything back. The stuff in Georgia, he told the guy, you know, see. So all of the major social, political, cultural religious forces are pushing us apart into separate camps. Yeah. Itd be hard for everybody to find. I live in Tennessee. And the best federalist paper. And I do like to listen to Tucker Carlson and Hannity and Laura. The Declaration of Independence was basically announcing them as not the thirteen colonies but as the first thirteen states of the U.S. Well, then I stand you know, more afraid. The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. However, there is a difference that makes the American revolution succeeded while the French revolution doesnt. This is ridiculous. In Haiti, slaves brought over by the French who captured the island, and forced them into brutal labor in what was the most valuable and wealthy are at the time. Lets listen. Understandably, the other European monarchs were pretty shocked. And then became socialized differently through the course of Donald Trump. Kristen Soltis Anderson, I believe, And, Kristen, Im sorry, Im misattributing this to you, but I remember hearing an interview where youre talking about polling Republicans and how important the person at the top of the ticket is to Republican views on issue after issue after issue. Both these revolutions had the similar cause, effects, and stages that resulted or started them. And so I just felt like I was watching a rerun of all kinds conversations Ive had from everything around dinners and restaurants locally to conversations with old friends.